Review goes hands-on w a fake $100 iPhone 16 & the grave security holes that come with it

The market of counterfeit Apple products has been well documented in the past, with offerings ranging from knockoff AirPods to deceivingly well-designed Apple Watch clones. Now, a new report from GeeksChalk examines a counterfeit iPhone 16 purchased for $100…

iPhone 16

Right off the bat, in terms of design, the counterfeit iPhone 16 largely resembles one you’d buy from an Apple Store:

The phone looks like an iPhone 16. It has the same form factor, most of the same detailing, no home button, the same volume rockers, Action Button, Camera Control and side button, a working USB-C port, and the same speaker holes on the bottom of the phone. It also has pentalobe screws on the bottom of the device, just like an iPhone.

The packaging is also eerily similar, with the same “Designed by Apple in California” branding and a paper insert explaining how to use Face ID. There’s even an IMEI number printed on the side of the box that corresponds to a legitimate iPhone 16.

Once you turn the device on, however, it becomes abundantly clear that this is not the real deal. The Dynamic Island along the top is purely software-created, while the display doesn’t actually extend all the way to the bottom of the chassis.

Perhaps one of the most humorous parts of the setup process on this “iPhone 16” was setting up Face ID:

I clicked over to Face ID in the settings menu, clicked “Add a Face ID,” and was hilariously bounced over to the camera, which did manage to draw a green box around my face. It said “Face Added,” and closed. I was then able to unlock the phone with my face. So was literally anyone else who put their face in front of the phone.

Elsewhere throughout the OS, it’s abundantly clear the device runs a skinned version of Android. The so-called App Store crashes regularly, displaying a popup that reads “Google Play Store” has crashed. Opening “Apple Maps” actually just opens Google Maps, “Podcasts” opens the YouTube app, and more.

Most importantly of all, however, are the grave security concerns that come with using a device like this. GeeksChalk worked with Trail of Bits senior security engineer Eric Kilmer to break down just how insecure this counterfeit iPhone 16 really is:

According to Eric, the phone runs a version of Android with a patchwork of code taken from several different sources. The phone is also loaded with backdoors and malicious apps.

The apps, which appear to come from several different online sources, is where it “gets really bad,” as Eric put it in the report shared with GeeksChalk. Security features such as permissions, regulation, or sandboxing (which keep a vulnerability in one app from affecting other parts of the phone) are “almost non-existent.”

Several of the stock fake Apple apps such as Compass, Stocks, Clock ask for “invasive permissions,” such as reading text messages. It’s unclear if this is a sign that the developers were mediocre or malicious, Eric wrote.

While you might not ever be in the position of accidentally (or purposefully) buying a counterfeit iPhone 16, it’s incredibly clear there is a market for such a device. The one highlighted by GeeksChalk was purchased in Shenzhen, China, and that $100 price tag makes it an enticing, but unwise purchase, for someone looking to get an iPhone 16-esque design on a budget.

Read GeeksChalk’s full piece for additional details.

Leave a Comment

Discover more from iPhoneGeeks

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading